Update, 29/01/2021: The day after I wrote this post, the role of the critic was suddenly thrust into the news due to Carey Mulligan’s allegations of misogyny levelled against a Variety reviewer and the associated responses. My headline is not meant to be a reflection of, nor cast an opinion on, those issues, except insofar as a critic will unavoidably bring his or her own biases to their review.
When I inherited management of the OFU website in 1998 or so, it was a fairly basic affair … and my lack of knowledge of HTML tended to keep it that way, until Joe’s revamp in 2000 finally did away with the prevailing Geocities vibe.
One of the features that I inherited was a modest collection of brief film reviews, in support of exhibition seasons past. At some point I decided that this was a great idea. I ended up writing a review not only of every OFU film, but every film I watched at the cinema or at home as well. This habit lasted for more than a decade, spilling over onto my personal website and totalling at least four hundred individual reviews, before I finally realised a couple of very important truths:
- Nobody was reading anything that I wrote.
- My reviews were terrible.
I’ve recently become more keenly aware that a lot of what I wrote in my late teens / early twenties was pretty rubbish, but it’s worth exploring exactly why writing film reviews was especially hard. Much of this analysis could also be applied to other forms of artistic criticism as well.
There’s no such thing as objectivity
Writing a film review is not a scientific process. Imagine a world in which a review were completely objective: then every critic would agree, and every review would describe precisely the same positive and negative aspects of the experience.
Successfully conveying the reviewer’s subjective experience of the film is integral to the purpose of a review. It’s what convinces the reader that the opinion is valid, thus influencing the reader’s own desire to seek out the film, and perhaps also her perception of the film.
There are some professionals whose reviews tend to be largely a recap of the plot. This does not adequately tell the reader about the experience; such reviews feel pointlessly mundane, and often the star-rating seems at odds with the review content because there is no evidence to back it up. But whereas this technique might just about work in the context of a film review – “Ah, it’s a sci-fi movie from Christopher Nolan that’s three hours long, sounds just my cup of tea” – apply the same idea to other areas of criticism and it’s clear we’re missing vital context and opinion: “Deep purple colour, smoky notes on the nose, velvety mouth-feel, hints of chocolate and tobacco.” But is it any good?
There must be a balance here. The reviewer must be conscious of the absolute merits of the film as well as their own preferences, because naturally …
Tastes and biases change
I cringe when I read some of the effusive praise I gave to certain mediocre films. But, especially when young, our tastes tend to reflect those of our peers. I’d rate a romance higher if I were on a date. (This rarely happened.) I’d rate a comedy higher if I were out with a group of friends. I’d rate The Matrix as one of the greatest films ever made on first viewing in a cinema, and a crushing disappointment when revisiting it fifteen years later.
Critics and audiences sometime diverge in their opinion of a film, which is why review aggregation websites usually include both measures. Nonetheless, most films do achieve a critical consensus – whether negative or positive. This means that there must be a degree of objectivity at play. It seems most likely that audiences are led by their emotional reaction to a film, whereas professional reviewers are able partially to set aside their personal preferences and instead rate the film relative to comparable others. But that means …
The reviewer needs to know more about the history of film than the director does
Kim Newman and Mark Kermode are prime examples of film geeks. They know so much about the obscure history of film that they can identify every influence on a director. This, at least, is the underlying premise of their Secrets of Cinema series which compellingly purports to find links back from this superhero action flick to that mid-century European arthouse picture.
If a critic is to pick up on the clues to a director’s influences, it stands to reason that they must know a wider range of films than the director himself does. And this is true also of the overarching language of cinema, in which the critic must be completely fluent: stories are told, or enhanced, by established conventions in framing, in lighting, in musical cues. Goldman makes the same point.
When I started writing film reviews, I was a very keen amateur. I joined OFU at Freshers’ Fair because I considered myself to be a film-lover. I could quote chunks of dialogue from Ghost, Groundhog Day and The Little Mermaid. Wasn’t that the very definition of a film fanatic?
But how did this skill help me to analyse and deconstruct new films? It didn’t, of course. I clearly did not know more about film than the director.
So I frequently ended up cheating a bit. My usual technique was to read film reviews as widely as possible and then cherry-pick the bits that I agreed with. This approach obviously came with its own biases: I would feel much more generous to a film if I’d read a slew of glowing reviews about it. However dishonest, this technique at least spared me from the most embarrassing error a film reviewer can make: basing a criticism on a fundamental misunderstanding of the film.
Although I was a long-time subscriber to Empire magazine, it was the BFI’s Sight & Sound magazine that was my key ally here. It had three features that made it uniquely suitable for inspiration (or plagiarising):
- It made a point of providing a detailed review of every single film released.
- It gave a thorough overview of the plot – frequently highlighting events or characters that had particular significance to the overall meaning of the film.
- The actual criticism of the film was overwhelmingly high-brow, no matter how trashy the film itself – providing plenty of references and comparisons.
Without reading other people’s reviews, as a teenager, I probably could not have understood Toy Story to be a reflection on parenting, and nor could I have known that O Brother, Where Art Thou? was based heavily on Homer’s Odyssey. Thus was I spared the potential credibility-ruining risk of failing to spot some blunt metaphor or reference that would have been blindingly obvious to someone with more literary or cinematic experience.
Very occasionally, professional critics do fall into this trap. Peter Bradshaw’s otherwise gushing recent review of Pixar’s Soul spends an entire paragraph on misreading a crucial scene, describing a well-established cinematic trope as “confusing”.
We may often disagree, but it’s hard not to fall in line with the consensus
People used to ask me, “OK, then, Review Boy. What’s the best film?” And if I were feeling honest, I’d say: “I don’t know. But my favourite film is …”
People would ask me, “What’s the worst film?” And I’d take particular pleasure in saying: “Oh, that’s easy. It’s Speed 2: Cruise Control.”
And it was easy. Because the friends that I’d seen it with agreed it was terrible, and so did all the critics.
For all the reasons above, and because I didn’t know any better, my reviews would agree with critical consensus more often than not. It works both ways: it’s a well-known cognitive bias that we seek out confirmation of our views, so there is a considerable amount of glee to be found in reading a favourite critic’s devastating take-down of a film we didn’t enjoy. Or even one we had no intention of ever seeing. There is a gloriously rich genre of criticism that gives infinitely more pleasure than the work under review. This is true especially when talking down things that are nominally unattainable anyway.
Very occasionally, though, I found myself in complete disagreement with the critical consensus. And that was a difficult position to be in: now I couldn’t rely on cherry-picking third-party reviews, but had to find my own voice to explain my dissenting opinion. (These days, the Internet being full of attention-seeking contrarians, it’s easy to find somebody arguing against even the most universally-loved films.)
Perhaps the most memorable example I encountered was Closer, a film that was highly regarded on first release. What a team! Marber! Nicholls! Portman! Roberts! Law! Owen! Ah, but I thoroughly hated it. It became the only film I’d ever seen that I switched off part way through, before resolving to plough on, and then switching it off a second time.
It was ironic, then, that this terrible experience can only have made me a better critic, by forcing me to find my own words to describe my visceral dislike of the work.
This is not the same thing as simply feeling ambivalence towards a work that others enjoy. I’ve personally never found Star Wars to be especially entertaining, but I absolutely respect the pleasure that it gives to others; I’d never try to convince a friend that they were wasting their time with it.
At the other end of the scale, I’ve occasionally found myself talking-up a film that others didn’t understand or see the point of. And that’s when we realise that …
We love what we love, even despite its flaws
It’s a tough call, but The Princess Bride is up there in the very top handful of my favourite films. It is a magical experience every time I watch it. It includes:
Fencing, fighting, torture, revenge, giants, monsters, chases, escapes, true love, miracles.
Peter Falk as The Grandfather, in William Goldman’s The Princess Bride (dir. Rob Reiner, 1987)
And even that list doesn’t do it justice. I love and cherish this film.
But … if somebody had initially told me, “This is the best film ever!” and then I watched it for the first time in a foul mood, while multi-tasking, then here’s what I might have thought:
- This script is cheesy beyond belief.
- That lighting is terrible – they are clearly in a studio the whole time.
- There’s no way that Fezzik is really climbing that rope.
- The stuntman playing Princess Buttercup has a rather obvious beard.
- Why does the soundtrack to this medieval-era film sound like it’s all been produced on synthesisers?
- The ROUS looks like a cheap rat costume off of Ebay.
- There’s some properly dodgy sexual politics going on.
We’re back to the problem of objectivity once again. When we have a negative emotional response to a film, it’s often easy to justify: we are disgusted; we are bored by a lazy plot; we are offended by clunky dialogue; we find the execution amateurish and risible. But when we feel positively towards a work, it’s often much more difficult to describe exactly why. Yes, we are delighted, and we are entertained; but how?
That might be the very reason that art exists at all – to express ideas that defy rational discussion. It’s particularly true of music; many people can be moved to tears by a particular song, but very few can then analyse their emotions to justify why. It’s true also of comedy, a notoriously subjective medium: what you find hilarious leaves me completely unmoved.
I’m going to give one final example from outside the world of film. In the Uffizi in Florence, there hangs a well-known painting by Botticelli. It’s extremely familiar to most of us. It has been digitised by the Google Arts and Culture team at extremely high resolution – some 565 megapixels – allowing anyone to examine it in microscopic detail. Despite all that, I cannot begin to describe the impact of seeing it in situ. It is absolutely extraordinary.
On the one hand, I can point to some specific things that I think are particularly impressive about it. The emotion in Venus’s eyes; the painstaking detail of her flowing hair; the luminosity of the fabrics worn by the goddesses on either side.
On the other hand, as someone who has glanced at a reproduction on their phone, you might argue: her neck is too long; her stance is impossible (she’s off-balance); and why does Venus’s left ankle and foot look like it’s been mutilated?
To which I’d say: it doesn’t matter. None of that matters. We love what we love. If it turns out that other people love something, enough to write positive reviews, then maybe it’s worth giving it a chance. If it turns out we love it too, then great. And if we don’t, that’s fine too.
My reviews
Looking back through my archive, there are a surprising number of movies listed that I now don’t even remember watching; perhaps these reviews may usefully serve as a warning to present-day Me to avoid wasting my time twice, but many of them seem to have slipped into complete obscurity anyway.
Here are a handful of extracts from reviews that I wrote in the period 1998 – 2008 or thereabouts. I am willing to stand behind some of the comments … but by no means all. I’ve selected some of my top-rated and bottom-rated films because, even if my opinion has changed since, these were surely sincerely held views at the time and less likely to have been biased by external factors. For example, I can well imagine that a solid three-star film would have received an extra star if I were on a date (looking at you, Notting Hill).
Can you guess the film in each case? I’ve mentioned some of them above, while a couple are pretty obscure.
***** There simply are not enough words in the English language to adequately express the effect that watching this movie for the first time has. It is awe-inspiring and totally involving. Admittedly, in the cold light of day after the film it is easy to see that the plot does not hold water; but when it is this much fun, who cares?
***** Stunning from start to finish, with cinema’s greatest chase sequence; a brilliant mirrored plot (in which elements of the first chase are reused when the hunter becomes the hunted); spectacular stunts (all performed live); and all offset by that gorgeous Davis score, which weaves in Yankee and Confederate themes such that the intertitles become completely redundant. A gem.
***** Two Oscar-worthy performances and both playing against type. [The] special effects are frequently astounding and occasionally completely breathtaking. For the most part, they are camera tricks rather than digital post-production, which gives them an immediacy lacking in many recent films. Ultimately, though, this isn’t a film about special effects and nor is it simply being clever with its reverse timeline. It’s charming, sometimes funny and sometimes moving, but its twin morals are what makes [the film] so heartwarming and so memorable: first, that we need our memories of hurtful times to make sense of the memories of happier times; and second, that there is, after all, a certain something that means that we are romantically drawn to particular people. Sometimes, it is just meant to be, no matter how hard we try to forget. Could there be a more romantic conclusion to a film?
* There were two good things about this film. The first was it ended quite quickly and I never have to see it again. The second was discussing how awful it was afterwards on the way home. With Keanu Reeves sensibly deciding not even to board the ill-fated ship or, indeed, the film, the remaining cast do their worst and end up appearing to ad-lib half the film, and just over-act the other half.
* A lamentable, charmless, exceptionally derivative and unfunny animation which sees Sony borrowing shamelessly from the leaders in this field (Pixar and Dreamworks). The central buddy pairing of lumbering, complex oaf and fast-talking impulsive sidekick is ripped off directly from Shrek, only in a completely implausible way and without any trace of spark. We can’t care about these unlikeable idiots. A terrible waste of time.
* After seeing a run of really good films at the cinema, it is refreshing to find one so utterly bad. Despite the presence of Goldblum and Murphy, or perhaps because of it, this alleged comedy never gets off the ground. If you have seen the trailer, then you have seen all the funny bits in the entire film. To recap: Murphy makes a drink for Goldblum then, when he has taken a sip, tells him it is made from his own urine; Murphy walks across three lanes of traffic without looking and survives; and that’s it, really. The film is of average length but it just seemed to go on … and on … and on. Just don’t bother.
* Some other reviewers have described this as a love story, which beggars belief. There is no love on display anywhere in this sick, twisted mess. There is a puppy-like co-dependency between certain characters, but at best this could be described as bitter masochism. There is no respect, there is no empathy. There is no love. Right at the end of the film, a transformation in one of the characters is supposed to have taken place, in which she has gained such inner strength from surviving her various ordeals that she – literally – exudes some mystic beauty that forces men to turn and stare at her. This scene is nothing short of excruciating, but nicely sums up the film that precedes it: shallow, unrealistic and horrible. There are only six credited actors in the film – four leads and two bit-parts. Even one of the bit-parts manages to be fairly unpleasant.
